After a trial on the debtor’s objection to the claim filed by her ex-husband, the court ruled the debtor should receive credit for alimony and property settlement payments made directly to the creditor.
The parties’ divorce decree provided for the debtor to pay her former husband monthly “alimony” payments and property settlement payments that by the terms of the decree were to be used to pay down joint debt. The debtor was not responsible for paying monthly child support to her former husband as the custodial parent, but both parties were to equally share the children’s medical and day care expenses.
The debtor paid more than $34,000 in alimony and property settlement payments directly to her former husband for four years. He considered the payments to be applicable to the children’s expenses. After her former husband made legal demands and garnished her wages for past-due alimony and property settlement payments, the debtor filed this Chapter 13 case. The former husband filed a bankruptcy claim for priority domestic support, and the debtor objected.
The bankruptcy court ruled that the debtor proved the payments were for alimony under the terms of the divorce decree, and that her payments directly to the creditor rather than through the state court does not disqualify their applicability to the alimony judgment and property settlement. As a result, the creditor has an unsecured priority claim under § 507(a)(1)(A) for unpaid alimony in the principal amount of $4,443.43, plus interest of $24.15, for a total of $4,467.58. The creditor also holds a general unsecured claim for the unpaid property settlement judgment in the principal amount of $57,600, plus interest of $1,442.60, for a total of $59,042.60.